Trouble in paradise?

It feels like a rogue forecast of a cyclone headed for New Zealand. The global financial storm was headed our way, but now it seems there’s optimism, or perhaps complacency, in the air. As usual the damage has been more severe for those on low incomes and the vulnerable, particularly children. But what about our region – the Pacific? A new report by Oxfam reveals that the storm hit our Pacific neighbours harder and for longer. But there is little hard data on how the crisis is affecting people who are vulnerable. The stories we are hearing give real cause for concern.

The report shows that, at a macroeconomic level, the Pacific as a whole may have avoided the most severe impacts of the economic crisis, but the impact is being felt to varying degrees across individual countries. While Papua New Guinea and Timor-Leste are being propped up by resource booms, other countries, including Kiribati, Samoa, the Solomon Islands, Tonga and Tuvalu are suffering.

They’re being affected by a combination of falling exports and government revenues, declining remittances, a fall in revenue from tourism and a loss in the value of trust funds. The fall in government revenue is already leading to cuts in health and education spending in some countries.

Overall, the crisis is reducing economic growth in Pacific countries and the majority of economies are likely to have contracted on a per capita basis last year - and are predicted to do so again in 2010.

This gives us an indication of the big picture. But there is no statistical data to track the impact the crisis is having on people’s lives at a household and community level.

Speculating about the impact of the crisis on everyday life using macroeconomic data is not appropriate for the Pacific. The existence of strong traditional social support systems and large extended family groups can help provide people with resilience during times of crisis. In some countries, a large proportion of the population lives a subsistence or semi-subsistence lifestyle on communally owned land.

Standard economic relationships don’t always hold up in the Pacific. Economic growth has not always benefitted the local population and government spending does not always lead to improvements in health and education.

Yet knowing how Pacific households are being affected is crucial to getting the response to the crisis right, and this is something Governments and agencies like Oxfam must now put an emphasis on discovering . We need to know if people are being forced to eat less, sell their assets or borrow more money. These effects will reduce well-being and people’s chances of escaping poverty.

It’s time for New Zealand, and the international community, to rethink the way we view economics in the Pacific and consequently the way we can support the region through the financial crisis. To do this, we need firstly to help establish systems to better monitor the impact of the crisis and any future economic downturns at a household level.

Secondly, we need to examine how traditional support systems can be strengthened to help people through crisis, or where these systems are not meeting people’s needs, determine what additional support can be offered.

Thirdly, we must provide governments with budget support, to help ensure that vital social expenditures such as health and education are not cut, as well as examine ways social spending can be improved to make it more effective. And it is crucial that there is support to community leaders and civil society to ensure that the money gets through and results in clean water, proper sanitation, better healthcare and education for all children.

Finally, donors must resist the temptation to impose their own economic solutions onto the Pacific, using the crisis as a means to push inappropriate trade liberalisation. Pacific governments need to engage with their parliaments, traditional leaders and civil society to devise policies which ensure that economic growth leads to real benefits for all people. This will ensure that everyone in the region gains from improvements in global economic conditions.

Barry Coates, Executive Director, Oxfam New Zealand

Article type: 
Press release